Medical Loss Ratio Fraud
WHAT IS MEDICAL LOSS RATIO FRAUD?
Medical Loss Ratio (MLR) is a financial measurement set by the Affordable Care Act (ACA) to encourage health plans to provide quality care to enrollees. Medical Loss Ratio fraud occurs when false information about profits or medical costs is reported to the government. Whistleblowers are essential to detecting and preventing this type of fraud, and ultimately protecting and bringing justice to the health care system.
Insurance companies collect premiums from policyholders to pay for a policyholder’s health care coverage as well as overhead costs. But the ACA requires that most health insurance providers spend at least 80% or 85% of premium income on medical care and improving services, leaving the remaining 20% or 15% for administrative costs. For example, if an insurer spends 80 cents of every policy holder’s premium dollar on medical claims and improving the quality of care, then the company has a medical loss ratio of 80%. The remaining 20 cents of each premium dollar can then be spent on overhead expenses like marketing, salaries and administrative costs.
MEDICAL LOSS RATIO FRAUD IN MEDICARE & MEDICAID
A typical healthcare insurance transaction involves a patient receiving care and the payer, or an insurance company, paying a fixed fee for that service. This prevalent form of healthcare payment is known as a “fee-for-service” model.
However, managed care fixed fee is another payment structure that is gaining prevalence in Medicare and Medicaid systems. Unlike the traditional arrangement, Medicare and Medicaid partner with and pay managed care organizations to provide healthcare services. Medicare or Medicaid pays an organization a fixed fee (set based on demographic and health information about that patient) that acts as an insurance premium for each enrolled policyholder.
Out of the founded concern that managed care organizations would pocket a large part of this fee rather than spend it on health services for the member, the ACA mandates that these organizations meet an MLR of at least 85%. The organizations cannot spend more than 15% of the fee on administrative costs, employee salaries, or marketing, nor simply keep the amount for profit. Organizations are subject to penalties if they fail to meet this MLR rate. If the managed care organizations do not meet the MLR requirements, they face a variety of penalties including:
- Refunding fee to the government
- Prohibition from enrolling new members
- Termination of their contract with the federal government
TYPES OF MEDICAL LOSS RATIO FRAUD
Since the end game of MLR fraud is to report an acceptable MLR of 80% or 85%, it can take a variety of forms. Some of the more common examples of MLR fraud include:
- Paying claims by providers that should have been denied under Medicare rules in order to increase the amount of spending on medical services
- Making payments to providers that are excessive to increase medical services spending
- Hiding or misallocating revenue from one contract to the next
- Reporting false medical costs or profits to make the MLR appear higher than it is
- Falsely classifying administrative expenses as medical spending in order to fraudulently adjust the MLR
To a managed care organization that depends on the government for a substantial part of their revenue, any of these consequences are disastrous for their bottom line. Managed care organizations, driven by their need to continue to receive government money, may engage in MLR fraud to avoid these consequences and keep money that they cannot legally keep.
MLR fraud is complicated and, by definition, highly concealed conduct. It is difficult for the government to dive into the minutia, mountainous paperwork, and transactions that managed care organizations deal in and use to defraud the government. This is why whistleblowers are essential to detecting and reporting MLR fraud—they can help protect and bring justice to the health care system. A whistleblower lawyer has the knowledge and ability to navigate the complexities of legal and health care system.
WHISTLEBLOWER PROTECTION & SETTLEMENTS
Managed care organizations that are paid through Medicare or Medicaid do so in accordance to an agreement with the federal government. This means that they are subject to the False Claims Act (FCA). When a managed care organization commits MLR fraud, it makes a false claim for payment because it did not have the legal MLR that entitles it to the funds.
The FCA allows a whistleblower to file suit on behalf of the government to recoup funds spent on fraudulent claims for payment. When whistleblowers file these suits, they do so under seal, making them confidential.
The FCA also provides employment protection for whistleblowers. This means they cannot be fired or disciplined for filing an FCA case. Additionally, the FCA entitles a whistleblower to an award in the case of a successful recovery for the government. This amount can range between 10% and 30% of the total recovered plus costs and fees depending on the information given and the role of the government in the litigation.
These awards can be significant in Medical Loss fraud cases. For example, a managed care organization agreed to pay the government $137.5 million to settle allegations that it inflated medical care spending to maintain an acceptable MLR. The whistleblowers in that case received more than $25 million as their award.
WHY YOU NEED A WHISTLEBLOWER LAWYER
Cases under the FCA are some of the most procedurally complicated in our civil justice system. MLR fraud liability under the FCA is continually evolving, which is why an experienced and knowledgeable legal representation is key in MLR cases. A well-intentioned whistleblower unaware of their rights can easily get lost in the complication of a lawsuit.
The attorneys at Price Armstrong have experience in representing whistleblowers and have successfully pursued several FCA claims. If you have knowledge of MLR fraud, contact a MLR whistleblower attorney at Price Armstrong for a no-cost, no-obligation consultation.
CONTACT US FOR A FREE CASE EVALUATION
If you have evidence of medical loss ratio fraud, contact the attorneys at Price Armstrong. We can help you seek justice and protect your rights throughout the process. Call us today at (205) 208-9588 for a free initial consultation and review of your case. Let us fight for you – call now!